More Poor vs. Poorer – Which is Correct?
“Poorer” is the standard and most commonly accepted comparative form of the adjective “poor.” While “more poor” is grammatically permissible in specific contexts, particularly for emphasis or when “poor” functions as a predicate adjective, “poorer” is generally preferred for conciseness and idiomatic flow in most comparative statements.
More Poor or Poorer – Which is Correct?
Both “poorer” and “more poor” can be considered grammatically correct, but “poorer” is overwhelmingly the more common, natural, and idiomatic choice in modern English. “Poorer” is the regular comparative form of the adjective “poor,” following the standard rule of adding “-er” to one-syllable adjectives. “More poor” is a less frequent construction, typically reserved for specific stylistic reasons or when “poor” is used in an absolute sense or as part of a predicate adjective phrase where “more” emphasizes the degree.
To decide which to use, consider that “poorer” sounds more natural and is always correct for direct comparison. “More poor” might be used for emphasis or to avoid repetition if “poor” is part of a longer phrase, but it often sounds less natural to native speakers.
| Word | Part of Speech | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poorer | Comparative Adjective | Having less wealth or quality than something else; more impoverished. | The second village was visibly poorer than the first. |
| More Poor | Comparative Adjective Phrase | Having a greater degree of poverty or low quality; emphasizes the state of being poor. | With each passing year, the region became more poor and desperate. |
How to Use Poorer
“Poorer” is the standard comparative form of the adjective “poor” and is used to indicate a greater degree of poverty, inferiority, or deficiency when comparing two or more things. It is concise, grammatically regular, and the preferred choice in most contexts. Use “poorer” when comparing economic status, quality, or condition. It is suitable for both formal and informal writing.
Example 1: After losing his job, he found himself in a poorer financial state than ever before.
Example 2: The new product was of noticeably poorer quality compared to its predecessor.
Example 3: Developing nations often face significantly poorer health outcomes.
What are the different forms of Poorer?
“Poorer” is the comparative form of the adjective “poor.” The three degrees of comparison are:
- Positive: Poor (e.g., The family is poor.)
- Comparative: Poorer (e.g., This family is poorer than that one.)
- Superlative: Poorest (e.g., They are the poorest family in the town.)
Etymology of the word Poorer
The word “poor” derives from the Old French povre, which itself came from the Latin pauper, meaning “poor, not wealthy.” The comparative suffix “-er” has Germanic origins and has been a standard way to form comparatives for one-syllable adjectives in English since Old English times.
Just as with ‘poor,’ navigating other comparative and superlative forms, like worse vs. worst, requires careful attention to context.
How to Use More Poor
“More poor” is a grammatically acceptable but less common and often less idiomatic way to form the comparative of “poor.” It is sometimes used for emphasis or in constructions where “poor” functions as a predicate adjective, particularly if the speaker wishes to highlight the absolute state of being poor rather than simply making a direct comparison of degree. It can also appear in older texts or specific dialects. While not strictly incorrect, it can sound clunky or overly formal to modern ears compared to “poorer.”
Example 1: The drought made the already struggling farmers even more poor and desperate.
Example 2: He argued that the new policy would leave the working class more poor, not less.
Example 3: The artist’s later works were considered more poor in execution than his earlier masterpieces.
What are the different forms of More Poor?
“More poor” is a comparative construction. The base adjective is “poor.” The forms are generally:
- Positive: Poor (e.g., The conditions are poor.)
- Comparative: More poor (e.g., The conditions became more poor over time.)
- Superlative: Most poor (e.g., These are the most poor conditions imaginable.)
However, it’s important to reiterate that “poorer” and “poorest” are the standard and preferred forms for comparative and superlative degrees of “poor.”
Etymology of the word More Poor
“More” comes from the Old English māra, meaning “greater, larger, more numerous.” It is used to form the comparative of multi-syllable adjectives (e.g., “more beautiful”) and some one-syllable adjectives for emphasis or stylistic reasons. “Poor” has its etymological roots as described above. The phrase “more poor” is a grammatical construction using the adverb “more” to modify the adjective “poor,” indicating a higher degree.
Related Concepts
Understanding the proper use of “poorer” versus “more poor” relates directly to the rules of forming comparatives and superlatives for adjectives in English. Adjectives typically form their comparative and superlative degrees in one of two ways:
- Adding -er and -est: For most one-syllable adjectives (e.g., tall, taller, tallest; fast, faster, fastest) and some two-syllable adjectives ending in -y (e.g., happy, happier, happiest). “Poor” falls into this category, making “poorer” the regular comparative.
- Using “more” and “most”: For most two-syllable adjectives not ending in -y and all adjectives with three or more syllables (e.g., beautiful, more beautiful, most beautiful; important, more important, most important).
While “more” is generally reserved for longer adjectives, it can occasionally be used with one-syllable adjectives like “poor” for emphasis or stylistic variation, though it’s less common and often sounds less natural than the regular “-er” form. It’s crucial to avoid “double comparatives” like “more poorer,” which are grammatically incorrect.
Examples from Media and Literature
- “It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife. However little known the feelings or views of such a man may be on his first entering a neighbourhood, this truth is so well fixed in the minds of the surrounding families, that he is considered as the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters.” – Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice (While not using “poorer,” it sets the context of financial standing.)
- “Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them. But many are born poorer, achieve little, and have hardship thrust upon them.” – A modern paraphrase reflecting social commentary.
- “The economic forecast suggests that many families will find themselves in an even poorer situation by year-end.” – News report on financial trends.
- “He was not just poor; he was becoming more poor with every failed business venture.” – A descriptive passage emphasizing a worsening state.
- “Compared to the opulence of the king’s palace, the dwellings of the common folk were incredibly poorer.” – Historical fiction describing living conditions.
Practice Exercises
Choose the correct word to complete the sentence.
- After the storm, the coastal towns were left in a much (more poor / poorer) condition.
- She felt (more poor / poorer) in spirit after hearing the sad news.
- The company’s performance was (more poor / poorer) this quarter than last.
- With rising inflation, many households are becoming (more poor / poorer) each day.
- He described his childhood as (more poor / poorer) than his friend’s, who had everything.
Answer Key
- poorer
- poorer
- poorer
- poorer
- poorer
Poorer Synonyms
| Synonym | Definition |
|---|---|
| Needier | Having a greater lack of necessities or resources. |
| More impoverished | Having been made more poor or reduced to poverty. |
| More destitute | Having a greater lack of money, property, or means of subsistence. |
| Less wealthy | Possessing a smaller amount of money, property, or valuable possessions. |
| Inferior | Of lower quality or value. |
Frequently Asked Questions
Question 1: Is “more poorer” grammatically correct?
No, “more poorer” is a double comparative and is grammatically incorrect. You should use either “poorer” or “more poor,” but never both together.
Question 2: When might one choose “more poor” over “poorer”?
While less common, “more poor” might be chosen for stylistic emphasis, particularly when “poor” is used as a predicate adjective (e.g., “The plan made them more poor”) or in older or very formal contexts where the speaker wishes to highlight the absolute state rather than just a comparative degree. However, “poorer” is almost always the safer and more natural choice.
Question 3: Does “poorer” only refer to financial status?
No, while commonly used for financial status, “poorer” can also refer to a lower quality, condition, or standard (e.g., “The team’s performance was poorer this season,” or “The soil quality was poorer in the drought-stricken areas”).
Conclusion
In the choice between “more poor” and “poorer,” “poorer” stands as the overwhelmingly preferred, standard, and most natural comparative form of the adjective “poor” in modern English. It is concise, grammatically regular, and suitable for nearly all comparative contexts, whether referring to financial status, quality, or condition. While “more poor” is not strictly incorrect and can be found in specific stylistic or emphatic uses, it often sounds less idiomatic to native speakers. Pro Tip: To ensure clarity, conciseness, and adherence to standard English grammar in professional and everyday communication, consistently opt for “poorer” when forming the comparative of “poor.”
